Bumkins Silicone Straw Cup with Lid vs The First Years Take & Toss Straw Cups, 10 Oz Toddler Sippy Cups - 20 Pack

Side-by-side specs from each maker.

Only the differences are shown.

Bumkins Silicone Straw Cup with LidThe First Years Take & Toss Straw Cups, 10 Oz Toddler Sippy Cups - 20 Pack
TypeStraw cupStraw cup
Capacity7 ozNot listed
Drinks fromstrawstraw
Spills"spill-resistant", per the maker"spill-proof", per the maker
BPA-freeNot listedYes, per the maker
DishwasherYes, per the makerYes, per the maker
CareTop rack dishwasher only.Not listed
Age12m+18m+
FitsNot listedMaker sells Take & Toss replacement lids and straws

Bumkins Silicone Straw Cup with Lid

Silicone cup with a lid and straw, 7 oz, with a weighted bottom. Maker calls it spill-resistant and leak-resistant.

  • Weighted bottom to reduce tipping
  • Top rack dishwasher
  • Maker does not say whether the straw comes out
  • No handles listed

The First Years Take & Toss Straw Cups, 10 Oz Toddler Sippy Cups - 20 Pack

A multipack of reusable snap-lid toddler straw cups sold in a 20-pack.

  • Large multipack
  • Replacement lids and straws sold separately