Pacifier holders and stuffed pacifiers

Plush holders and attached pacifiers. Follow the maker's warnings.

Knit bunny pacifier holder and beaded pacifier clip on a cream blanket

10models tracked
$9 to $20price range

Pacifier holders and stuffed pacifiers by budget

The 6 pacifier holders and stuffed pacifiers with a published list price, split into thirds by price. A to Z within each lane. Price isn't a quality rating.

Mid-range$10 to $144

Splurge$14 and up2

All 10 pacifier holders and stuffed pacifiers

Must have:

✓ maker says yes ✕ maker says no ? not published Confirmed only Sort

Compare		Ages	Material		Silicone	Natural rubber	One piece
	Chicco NaturalFit Pocket Buddies Pacifier Holder	–	–	$9.99	?	?	?
	Dr. Brown's Lovey Blanket Pacifier and Teether Holder1-pack, includes a lightweight 100% silicone HappyPaci pacifier and a 100% silicone beaded teether ring; blanket described as soSilicone	HappyPaci pacifier 0-6m; Flexees teether ring 3m+	includes a lightweight	$11.99	✓	?	?
	Dr. Brown's Lovey Pacifier and Teether Holder1-pack, includes a 100% silicone HappyPaci pacifierSilicone	HappyPaci pacifier 0-6 months	includes a 100%	$9.99	✓	?	?
	Itzy Ritzy Bitzy Pal Natural Rubber Pacifier & Lovey1-pack, natural rubber nipple (Itzy Soother pacifier); plush made from soft cotton with embroidered detailsNatural rubber	0 months+	natural rubber nipple	$13.99	?	✓	?
	Itzy Ritzy Itzy Paci Pal (page meta title: Sweetie Pals)1-pack, soft siliconeSilicone	0 months+	polyester	$9.99	✓	?	?
	Philips Avent Soothie Snuggle1-pack, BPA-free medical grade silicone (pacifier) (per the maker)Silicone	0m+	BPA-free medical grade	–	✓	?	?
	Ryan & Rose Cutie Holder1-packDishwasher safeSiliconeOne piece	–	100% silicone	$20	✓	?	✓
	WubbaNub Detachable WubbaNub Pacifier1-pack, 100% silicone (pacifier is one piece)Air holes in shieldDishwasher safeSiliconeOne piece	pacifier 0-6m (teether 3m+)	100% silicone	–	✓	?	✓
	WubbaNub MLB Team Pacifiers (Boston Red Sox Bear page read)1-pack, 0-6m, babies that are not teething, latex free pacifierSiliconeNatural rubber	0-6m, babies that are not teething	100% silicone	–	✓	✓	?
	WubbaNub Pacifier (classic plush animals)1-pack, latex freeSiliconeNatural rubber	newborns less than six months of age and/or babies without	100% silicone pacifier	–	✓	✓	?

Pacifier holders and stuffed pacifiers by the numbers

The 10 we compare, from each maker's published specs. Ranges, not ratings.

Price$9.99 to $20; the middle half $9.99 to $13.99 (6 of 10 publish it)

Holders side by side

From each maker's listing. A dash means the maker doesn't say.

Holder	Pacifier detaches	How it attaches	Age label
Dr. Brown's Lovey Blanket Pacifier and Teether Holder	–	snap closure to keep a pacifier or teether attached	HappyPaci pacifier 0-6m; Flexees teether ring 3m+
Dr. Brown's Lovey Pacifier and Teether Holder	Yes	secure loops hold removable pacifiers and teethers	HappyPaci pacifier 0-6 months
Itzy Paci Pal Pacifier & Stuffed Animal (Sweetie Pals)	Yes	–	0 months+
Itzy Ritzy Bitzy Pal Natural Rubber Pacifier & Lovey	–	plush attaches to the included Itzy Soother pacifier; Easy to swap pacifier loop	0 months+
Philips Avent Soothie Snuggle	–	–	0m+
Detachable WubbaNub Pacifier	Yes	–	pacifier 0-6m (teether 3m+)
WubbaNub MLB Team Pacifiers (Boston Red Sox Bear page read)	–	–	0-6m, babies that are not teething
WubbaNub Pacifier (classic plush animals)	–	–	newborns less than six months of age and/or babies without

What to look for in pacifier holders and stuffed pacifiers

The range across every pacifier or teether here, with the typical middle half shaded and the shortlist marked.

Price

What it lists for at the maker or a major store. Sales move this often.

NaturalFit Pocket Buddies Pacifier Holder

$9.99middle $11.99$20

Typical: $9.99 to $13.99. 6 of 10 list it. Lowest price: NaturalFit Pocket Buddies Pacifier Holder.

Ask the meadow

Questions about pacifier holders and stuffed pacifiers

Answers come from each maker's published specs. Safety and health questions link to the agency or medical source.

Are pacifier clips OK for sleep?

Safe sleep: see the AAP's guide to safe sleep and NICHD Safe to Sleep. Check the label and the maker's instructions, and ask your pediatrician about your child.

Still wondering? Write to us at hello@cribpicks.com and we'll look it up.