Petunia Pickle Bottom Boxy Backpack vs Storksak St James Scuba Diaper Bag

The St James is 0.8 lb lighter. The St James lists for $4 less.

Only the differences are shown.

Petunia Pickle Bottom Boxy BackpackStorksak St James
TypeBackpackBackpack
List price$199$195Lowest price
Bag weight3 lb2.2 lbLightest
Size13.8 × 6.3 × 13.8 in13.4 × 6.7 × 14.6 in
Capacity19.6 LNot listed
Pockets77
Insulated bottle pockets2Not listed
Ways to carryBackpack, Crossbody, HandheldBackpack, Shoulder, Crossbody
Changing pad includedYesYes
Stroller strapsYesNot listed
Wipes pocketYesNot listed
Laptop sleeveYesNot listed
Water-resistant or wipe-cleanYesNot listed
Machine washableNoNo
MaterialVegan leatherette, water-resistantScuba with wipe-clean lining
Colors61

Petunia Pickle Bottom Boxy Backpack

A structured faux leather backpack with a zip-out changing station, wipes case and stroller straps. It can also be worn crossbody. Wipe clean, and only the pad is machine washable.

  • Changing station and pad included
  • Stroller straps included
  • Three carry options
  • No insulated pocket listed
  • List price $199

Storksak St James Scuba Diaper Bag

A light scuba diaper bag with convertible straps for backpack, shoulder or crossbody wear and expandable side panels.

  • Backpack, shoulder or crossbody
  • 7 pockets with expandable side panels
  • Changing mat and insulated food and bottle bag included
  • $195 regular price
Ask the meadow

Boxy Backpack or St James?

Answers come from each maker's published specs. Safety and health questions link to the agency or medical source.

Which is lighter?

The St James weighs 2.2 lb empty, versus 3.04 lb for the Boxy Backpack.

Is the St James cheaper than the Boxy Backpack?

Yes. $195 versus $199 list price.

Still wondering? Write to us at hello@cribpicks.com and we'll look it up.