Charlie Banana Newborn vs Thirsties One Size Pocket

Side-by-side specs from each maker.

Only the differences are shown.

Charlie Banana NewbornThirsties One Size Pocket
TypeCloth diaper (pocket)Cloth diaper (pocket)
Closuresnapssnaps
MaterialsWaterproof polyester outer; fleece lining; one XS insertNot listed
FabricOuter: waterproof polyester. Inner: fleeceNot listed
CareRemove solids and inserts; wash warm at 104F max with detergent without fabric softener; non-chlorine bleach ok, no chlorine bleach; line dry preferred, tumble low ok; no ironingSleeve design lets the diaper go in the wash without stuffing; inserts agitate out
Maker's use notesDesigned for 0 to 4 months and preemiesNot listed

Charlie Banana Newborn

Charlie Banana's newborn-size cloth diaper with a thinner XS insert, meant for roughly 0 to 4 months.

  • No weight range published in the FAQ

Thirsties One Size Pocket

Thirsties' pocket diaper with a fleece-style stay-dry lining and a snap-together two-part insert, sized to adjust with rise snaps.

  • Rise snaps adjust fit
  • Double insert can be sized down for smaller babies
  • Maker blog is dated and may not match current version