Charlie Banana One Size with Fleece vs Thirsties Natural One Size Pocket

Side-by-side specs from each maker.

Only the differences are shown.

Charlie Banana One Size with FleeceThirsties Natural One Size Pocket
TypeCloth diaper (pocket)Cloth diaper (pocket)
Sizes and weightsOne Size: 8–36 lbOne Size: 8–40 lb
Closuresnapssnaps
MaterialsWaterproof polyester outer; fleece lining; inserts of 4 microterry layers topped with fleece or hemp/cottonWaterproof TPU outer; 100% organic cotton inner; inserts of 55% hemp / 45% organic cotton (full size, 5 layers) and 100% organic cotton (newborn, 3 layers) (per the maker)
FabricOuter: waterproof polyester. Inner: fleeceOuter: waterproof TPU. Inner: 100% organic cotton (per the maker)
CareRemove solids and inserts; wash warm at 104F max with detergent without fabric softener; non-chlorine bleach ok, no chlorine bleach; line dry preferred, tumble low ok; no ironingWash and dry at least 3 times before use; pre-wash warm, wash hot, rinse warm; hang dry or tumble dry low

Charlie Banana One Size with Fleece

Charlie Banana's pocket-style one-size cloth diaper with fleece lining, three waist snaps and leg elastic settings, sold in 1, 3 or 5 packs.

    Thirsties Natural One Size Pocket

    A one-size pocket with a TPU shell, organic cotton inner and hemp/cotton inserts (per the maker). Double waist snap and rise snaps adjust the fit.

    • Natural-fiber inner and inserts
    • Fits roughly 8 to 40 lb
    • Natural fibers need several washes to reach full absorbency