BIBS Supreme Silicone Pacifier vs Playtex Baby Binky Orthodontic Pacifier With Snap On Cover (Wild and Cuddly Series)

The Supreme Silicone Pacifier has a symmetrical nipple; the Binky Orthodontic Pacifier With Snap On Cover (Wild and Cuddly Series), orthodontic. The Supreme Silicone Pacifier is natural rubber latex or silicone (both options offered); the Binky Orthodontic Pacifier With Snap On Cover (Wild and Cuddly Series) is Medical grade silicone nipple (per the maker). The Supreme Silicone Pacifier is listed for 1 (0+ months), 2 (6+ months); the Binky Orthodontic Pacifier With Snap On Cover (Wild and Cuddly Series) for 0 - 6 Months; 6 months and Older.

Only the differences are shown.

BIBS Supreme Silicone PacifierPlaytex Baby Binky Orthodontic Pacifier With Snap On Cover (Wild and Cuddly Series)
TypePacifierPacifier
List price$8.95$7.99
Sizes1 (0+ months), 2 (6+ months)0 - 6 Months; 6 months and Older
AgeNot listed0 - 6 Months; 6 months and Older
Nipple shapesymmetricalorthodontic
Materialnatural rubber latex or silicone (both options offered)Medical grade silicone nipple (per the maker)
Shieldfood-grade PPTritan shield and nub
Air holes in shieldYes, per the makerNot listed
SterilizingLatex nipples: scald regularly. Silicone nipples: scald or microwave using the proper techniqueNot listed
DishwasherNot listedYes, per the maker
BPA-freeYes, per the makerYes, per the maker
CarePull the nipple in all directions and inspect it before first use; sterilize new pacifiers after unpacking; replace every 4 to 6 weeks or at the first sign of damage or weakness.it can go in the dishwasher and microwave sterilizer.
Standards (maker's words)"Complies with 16 CFR 1511"Not listed

BIBS Supreme Silicone Pacifier

Wide-shield pacifier with a symmetrical drop-shaped nipple, ventilation openings in the PP shield, and a choice of latex or silicone nipple in two sizes.

  • Shield has ventilation openings
  • Latex or silicone nipple choice
  • The maker says it complies with 16 CFR 1511

Playtex Baby Binky Orthodontic Pacifier With Snap On Cover (Wild and Cuddly Series)

Orthodontic-shaped Binky with a vented, curved shield and a snap-on cover, sold in two age sizes and several prints.

  • Two age sizes
  • The maker lists dishwasher and microwave sterilizer care