BIBS Try-It Collection 3-Pack vs Comfy Cubs Silicone Pacifiers, 5 Pack

The Try-It Collection 3-Pack has a one each of round, anatomical and symmetrical nipple; the Silicone Pacifiers, 5 Pack, breast-like. The Try-It Collection 3-Pack is natural rubber latex; the Silicone Pacifiers, 5 Pack is 100% food-grade silicone (per the maker). The Try-It Collection 3-Pack comes 3 to a pack; the Silicone Pacifiers, 5 Pack, 5. The Try-It Collection 3-Pack is listed for Size 1; the Silicone Pacifiers, 5 Pack for from birth and up.

Only the differences are shown.

BIBS Try-It Collection 3-PackComfy Cubs Silicone Pacifiers, 5 Pack
TypePacifierPacifier
List price$19.95 for 3$19.99 for 5
In the pack35
SizesSize 1Not listed
AgeNot listedfrom birth and up
Nipple shapeone each of round, anatomical and symmetricalbreast-like
Materialnatural rubber latex100% food-grade silicone (per the maker)
Shieldfood-grade PPNot listed
Air holes in shieldNot listedYes, per the maker
SterilizingSterilize latex nipples regularly by scaldingNot listed
BPA-freeYes, per the makerYes, per the maker
CarePull the nipple in all directions and inspect it before first use; sterilize new pacifiers after unpacking; sterilize latex nipples regularly by scalding; replace every 4 to 6 weeks or at the first sign of damage or weakNot listed
Standards (maker's words)"Complies with 16 CFR 1511""meets CPSIA safety standards"

BIBS Try-It Collection 3-Pack

Three-pack of Size 1 latex pacifiers, one each with a round, anatomical and symmetrical nipple, sold so a family can compare shapes.

  • Three nipple shapes in one pack
  • The maker says it complies with 16 CFR 1511
  • Contains natural rubber latex
  • Size 1 only

Comfy Cubs Silicone Pacifiers, 5 Pack

Five-pack of silicone pacifiers with a breast-like nipple and two air holes, listed for babies from birth.

  • Five pacifiers per pack
  • Two air holes
  • The maker says it is free of BPA, PVC, phthalates and latex