Loulou Lollipop Teething Mitt vs Sprucely Cooling Teether

The Teething Mitt is One-piece molded food-grade silicone with an adjustable silicone strap (per the maker); the Cooling Teether is Food-grade silicone and EVA; filled with sterile water (per the maker). The Teething Mitt is listed for Roughly 2-6 months; the Cooling Teether for 0+.

Only the differences are shown.

Loulou Lollipop Teething MittSprucely Cooling Teether
TypeTeetherTeether
List price$12.95$12.19
AgeRoughly 2-6 months0+
MaterialOne-piece molded food-grade silicone with an adjustable silicone strap (per the maker)Food-grade silicone and EVA; filled with sterile water (per the maker)
One pieceYes, per the makerNot listed
FridgeNot listedYes
Freezer (maker)YesNo
Water or gel filledNot listedYes
SterilizingNot listedDo not boil, sterilize, microwave or place in the dishwasher
DishwasherYes, per the makerNot listed
BPA-freeYes, per the makerNot listed
CareWipe clean after each session or wash in warm soapy water; air dry. Maker FAQ specifies top-rack dishwasher.Wash with soapy water and allow to air dry.
Standards (maker's words)"CPSC and CPSIA tested"Not listed
Maker's use notesAwake, supervised use only.Cool only in the refrigerator; do not place in the freezer. Before each use, check for leaks or punctures; if damaged, discard and replace.

Loulou Lollipop Teething Mitt

One-piece silicone teething mitt with an adjustable strap, sold in four animal designs.

  • The maker lists freezer and top-rack dishwasher use
  • BPA, PVC, phthalate, lead and cadmium free
  • The maker lists awake, supervised use only
  • Age given only as a rough range

Sprucely Cooling Teether

Water-filled teether with a textured EVA cover, about 3.75 by 4.25 in, with a detachable design.

  • Clear maker instructions on chilling and care
  • Leak check needed before each use