Mushie Animal Ring Teethers vs Sprucely Cooling Teether

The Animal Ring Teethers is 100% high-quality food grade silicone (per the maker); the Cooling Teether is Food-grade silicone and EVA; filled with sterile water (per the maker). The Animal Ring Teethers is listed for 3 months+; the Cooling Teether for 0+.

Only the differences are shown.

Mushie Animal Ring TeethersSprucely Cooling Teether
TypeTeetherTeether
List price$12.99$12.19
Age3 months+0+
Material100% high-quality food grade silicone (per the maker)Food-grade silicone and EVA; filled with sterile water (per the maker)
FridgeNot listedYes
Freezer (maker)Not listedNo
Water or gel filledNot listedYes
SterilizingBoil for 5 minutes to sterilize; steam sterilizerDo not boil, sterilize, microwave or place in the dishwasher
DishwasherYes, per the makerNot listed
BPA-freeYes, per the makerNot listed
CareWash with warm water and mild soap, or clean on the top rack of the dishwasher or in a steam sterilizer. Avoid harsh or scented cleaners.Wash with soapy water and allow to air dry.
Standards (maker's words)"Third-party tested to meet CPSIA, ASTM, and Prop 65 standards"Not listed
Maker's use notesNot listedCool only in the refrigerator; do not place in the freezer. Before each use, check for leaks or punctures; if damaged, discard and replace.

Mushie Animal Ring Teethers

Silicone ring-style teether with animal faces, sold in Lion, Elephant, Koala and Dog options.

  • No freezer or fridge guidance stated
  • No item-specific warnings stated

Sprucely Cooling Teether

Water-filled teether with a textured EVA cover, about 3.75 by 4.25 in, with a detachable design.

  • Clear maker instructions on chilling and care
  • Leak check needed before each use