NUK First Choice Classic Pacifier, 0-6 months vs Philips Avent Super Soothie Pacifier, 3m+ (3-18m)

The First Choice Classic Pacifier, 0-6 months has a orthodontic (asymmetrical with a scooped bottom) nipple; the Super Soothie Pacifier, 3m+ (3-18m), rounded. The First Choice Classic Pacifier, 0-6 months is silicone nipples; the Super Soothie Pacifier, 3m+ (3-18m) is medical-grade silicone (per the maker). The First Choice Classic Pacifier, 0-6 months is listed for 0-6m, 6-18m, 18-36m; the Super Soothie Pacifier, 3m+ (3-18m) for 3-18m.

Only the differences are shown.

NUK First Choice Classic Pacifier, 0-6 monthsPhilips Avent Super Soothie Pacifier, 3m+ (3-18m)
TypePacifierPacifier
In the packNot listed2
Sizes0-6m, 6-18m, 18-36m3-18m
Age0-6m3-18m
Nipple shapeorthodontic (asymmetrical with a scooped bottom)rounded
Materialsilicone nipplesmedical-grade silicone (per the maker)
One pieceNot listedYes, per the maker
DishwasherYes, per the makerNot listed
BPA-freeYes, per the makerYes, per the maker
CareDishwasher top rack onlyNot listed
Maker's use notesNot listedFor hygiene reasons, replace pacifiers after 4 weeks of use

NUK First Choice Classic Pacifier, 0-6 months

An orthodontic-shaped silicone-nipple pacifier line in three size ranges, shown here in the 0-6m size.

  • Dishwasher top rack
  • Three size ranges
  • Pack of 3 in the text but a 5-pack option also shown

Philips Avent Super Soothie Pacifier, 3m+ (3-18m)

A two-pack of one-piece silicone pacifiers with a rounded nipple, listed by the maker for 3-18 months.

  • One-piece silicone construction as the maker describes it
  • Sold as a 2-pack