NUK First Choice Comfy 100% Silicone Pacifier, 0-6 months vs Ryan & Rose Cutie PAT Pacifier Kit (Pacifier Starter Kit)

The First Choice Comfy 100% Silicone Pacifier, 0-6 months has a breast-like (orthodontic) nipple; the Cutie PAT Pacifier Kit (Pacifier Starter Kit), five styles in the kit: Smile, Flat, Slant, Round, Bulb. The First Choice Comfy 100% Silicone Pacifier, 0-6 months is listed for 0-6m, 6-18m; the Cutie PAT Pacifier Kit (Pacifier Starter Kit) for Smile 0M+, Flat 0M+, Slant 0-6M, Round 0-6M, Bulb 0-6M.

Only the differences are shown.

NUK First Choice Comfy 100% Silicone Pacifier, 0-6 monthsRyan & Rose Cutie PAT Pacifier Kit (Pacifier Starter Kit)
TypePacifierPacifier
In the packNot listed5
Sizes0-6m, 6-18mSmile 0M+, Flat 0M+, Slant 0-6M, Round 0-6M, Bulb 0-6M
Age0-6m0M+ and 0-6M depending on style
Nipple shapebreast-like (orthodontic)five styles in the kit: Smile, Flat, Slant, Round, Bulb
Material100% medical-grade silicone (per the maker)100% medical-grade silicone (per the maker)
One pieceYes, per the makerYes, per the maker
Air holes in shieldNot listedYes, per the maker
DishwasherYes, per the makerYes, per the maker
BPA-freeYes, per the makerYes, per the maker
CareDishwasher top rack onlyWash with warm water and mild soap.
Maker's use notesNot listedPerform a pull test before each use and discard if there are cracks, tears or excessive wear. Nipple is for sucking, not chewing. Replace after 4 weeks of continued use. Use only with adult supervision. Do not tie around a child's neck. Use only with CPSC-compliant pacifier clips.

NUK First Choice Comfy 100% Silicone Pacifier, 0-6 months

A one-piece 100% silicone pacifier with a heart-shaped shield and a breast-like orthodontic nipple, sold in 0-6m and 6-18m sizes.

  • Dishwasher top rack
  • 3-pack and 5-pack options, no single pack count

Ryan & Rose Cutie PAT Pacifier Kit (Pacifier Starter Kit)

Starter kit with one each of five Cutie PAT nipple styles (Smile, Flat, Slant, Round, Bulb) in silicone.

  • Lets a family try five nipple shapes
  • One-piece silicone construction
  • Maker advises replacing after 4 weeks of use