Regalo Fabric Retractable Gate vs Toddleroo SmartFit Retractable Mesh Gate

The Fabric Retractable Gate fits up to 50 in; the SmartFit Retractable Mesh Gate (5548 / 5548S), up to 55 in. The Fabric Retractable Gate is 30 in tall; the SmartFit Retractable Mesh Gate (5548 / 5548S), 33 in.

Only the differences are shown.

Regalo Fabric Retractable GateToddleroo by North States SmartFit Retractable Mesh Gate (5548 / 5548S)
TypeRetractable gateRetractable gate
Mounthardwarehardware
Stairs (maker's words)Not stated by the makerNot stated by the maker
Fits openingsup to 50 inup to 55 in
Height30 in33 in
MaterialPlastic mounting system and PVC mesh barrier wallMetal and mesh
Age (maker)6-24 MonthsNot listed
Standards (maker's words)"Certified to Both BSA and ASTM Standards""Baby Safety Alliance and ASTM certified"
Maker's warningsMaker advises measuring the opening before purchase; hardware mount can be installed inside or on the outside of the opening.it for the bottom of stairs, hallways and doorways

Regalo Fabric Retractable Gate

A hardware-mounted retractable mesh gate up to 50 in wide with a turn-to-lock cap and lock indicator window.

  • Hardware mount inside or outside an opening
  • Lock indicator window
  • Maximum 50 in opening

Toddleroo SmartFit Retractable Mesh Gate

A hardware-mounted retractable mesh gate, 33 inches tall, for openings up to 55 inches, with a twist-and-lock latch and no threshold.

  • Retracts fully
  • No threshold
  • Mounts at any angle
  • Maker does not approve it for the top of stairs
  • Hardware mount only