Happiest Baby Sleepea Comforter Swaddle vs Love to Dream Swaddle UP Cotton Fleece (1.5 TOG)
The Swaddle UP Cotton Fleece (1.5 TOG) is lighter: 1.5 vs 2 TOG. The Sleepea Comforter Swaddle is convertible to arms out; the Swaddle UP Cotton Fleece (1.5 TOG) is arms up. The Swaddle UP Cotton Fleece (1.5 TOG) lists for $9 less.
Only the differences are shown.
| Happiest Baby Sleepea Comforter Swaddle | Love to Dream Swaddle UP Cotton Fleece (1.5 TOG) | |
|---|---|---|
| Type | Wrap or zip swaddle | Wrap or zip swaddle |
| List price | $46.95 | $37.95Lowest price |
| Sizes | Small: 5–12 lb, up to 20.5 in Medium: 12–18 lb, up to 23 in Large: 18–25 lb, up to 25 in X-Large: 23–25 lb, up to 28 in | Newborn: 5–8.5 lb, up to 24 in Small: 8–13 lb, up to 25 in Medium: 13–19 lb, up to 27 in |
| TOG | 2 | 1.5 |
| Arms | Converts to arms out | Arms up |
| Stop swaddling when | Not listed | Suitable from newborn to approximately 3 months or when baby is starting to show signs of rolling |
| Room for hips and legs | Not listed | Yes, per the maker |
| Closure | zipper, adjustable bands and shoulder snaps for arms out | 2-way zipper with chin zip guard |
| Material | 100% organic cotton shell, 100% recycled polyester fill (per the maker) | Outer 93% cotton, 7% elastane; lining 95% cotton, 5% elastane (brushed cotton fleece) |
| Organic | Yes, per the maker | Not listed |
| Machine washable | Yes | Yes |
| Maker's use notes | Not listed | Choose size by weight. Consult a healthcare professional first for babies born prematurely or with medical needs. |
Happiest Baby Sleepea Comforter Swaddle
Insulated organic cotton swaddle sack rated 2.0 TOG with bands for a snug wrap and snaps to leave arms out (per the maker).
- Warm 2.0 TOG
- Snaps for arms out
- No stop-swaddling guidance listed
Love to Dream Swaddle UP Cotton Fleece (1.5 TOG)
- Warmer fabric
- Arms-up design
- Two-way zipper
- Too warm for hot rooms
- Outgrown by about 3 months or first rolling
Sleepea Comforter Swaddle or Swaddle UP Cotton Fleece (1.5 TOG)?
Answers come from each maker's published specs. Safety and health questions link to the agency or medical source.
Is the Swaddle UP Cotton Fleece (1.5 TOG) cheaper than the Sleepea Comforter Swaddle?
Yes. $37.95 versus $46.95 list price.
Which is lighter?
The Swaddle UP Cotton Fleece (1.5 TOG) at 1.5 TOG versus 2 TOG for the Sleepea Comforter Swaddle. TOG is a fabric warmth rating. Each maker publishes its own room-temperature chart; use the chart for the product you have. Safe sleep: see the AAP's guide to safe sleep and NICHD Safe to Sleep. Check the label and the maker's instructions, and ask your pediatrician about your child.
Still wondering? Write to us at hello@cribpicks.com and we'll look it up.